Tag Archive for: KitKat

Atari Gets The Settlement It Was Surely Fishing For Over An Homage To ‘Breakout’ In KitKat Commercial

As readers of this site will know, once-venerated gaming giant Atari long ago reduced itself to an intellectual property troll mostly seeking to siphon money away from companies that actually produce things. The fall of one of gamings historical players is both disappointing and sad, given just how much love and nostalgia there is for its classic games. It was just that nostalgia that likely led Nestle to craft an advertisement in Europe encouraging buyers of candy to “breakout” KitKats and included imagery of the candy replacing a simulation of a game of Breakout. For this, Atari sued over both trademark and copyright infringement, stating for the latter claim that the video reproduction of a mock-game that kind of looks like Breakout constituted copyright infringement.

As we discussed in that original post, both claims are patently absurd. Nestle and Atari are not competitors and anyone with a working frontal lobe will understand that the ad was a mere homage to a classic game made decades ago. If the products aren’t competing, and if there is no real potential for public confusion, there is not trademark infringement. As for the copyright claim, the expression in the homage was markedly different from Atari’s original game, and there’s that little fact that Nestle didn’t actually make a game to begin with. They mocked up a video. Nothing in there is copyright infringement.

It was enough that I’m certain some of our readers wondered why Atari would do something like this to begin with. The answer is the recent news that a settlement has been reached in the lawsuit, and it was almost certainly that settlement that Atari was fishing for all along.

Vintage gaming company Atari has settled a lawsuit accusing Swiss foods giant Nestle of using one of its classic video games to sell Kit Kat bars to nostalgic gamers without permission. On Wednesday, U.S. District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers approved Atari’s request to voluntarily dismiss the case with prejudice.

Both parties reached a settlement during a conference in Magistrate Judge Sallie Kim’s courtroom on Dec. 12, 2017, according to court records. The terms of the agreement are confidential.

So, while we don’t know the terms of the settlement, it’s incredibly common for megaliths like Nestle to throw settlement money at pests like Atari to make them go away. The settlements are often not anything like the potential rewards for the plaintiff if the case had gone to trial, but that’s entirely besides the point. The point is to get the settlement. It’s essentially free money, after all, reliably gained by filing lawsuits trolling successful companies with spurious legal claims that at best skirt the line of what intellectual property laws actually say.

It’s for that reason that trolls like Atari seek treble and punitive damages in these suits, merely as a way to alter the risk calculation for the legal teams of their victims. A company like Nestle, worth hundreds of billions of dollars, has easy math to do when it comes to deciding how to make this all go away. The problem with this is, of course, that not every company has billions of dollars of revenue coming in. It’s the smaller companies that are truly victimized by IP trolls that fill their war chests with these kinds of easy settlements.

Permalink | Comments | Email This Story

Techdirt.

T-Mobile ZTE ZMAX gets November security updates… but it still runs Android 4.4.2 KitKat – Android Police


Android Police

T-Mobile ZTE ZMAX gets November security updates… but it still runs Android 4.4.2 KitKat
Android Police
I'm honestly conflicted. When I spotted this new software on T-Mobile's support pages, I had to do a double take. How come a phone that's still stuck on Android 4.4.2 KitKat is getting the November 2016 security updates? It's ridiculous and awesome to

android security – read more

Warning: Serious VPN Security Flaw Detected in Android Jelly Bean, KitKat – Gizbot


Gizbot

Warning: Serious VPN Security Flaw Detected in Android Jelly Bean, KitKat
Gizbot
Here's some serious threat for all those currently using devices running on Android Jelly Bean or KitKat. According to reports, a new Android security flaw has been discovered that affects the virtual private network of devices running on Jelly Bean or
Critical VPN security flaw detected in Android Jelly Bean, KitKat versions Firstpost
Android Jelly Bean, Kit Kat vulnerable to security flawTweakTown

all 26 news articles »

“android security” – read more

VPN bypass attack possible also on Android KitKat – Help Net Security

VPN bypass attack possible also on Android KitKat
Help Net Security
Posted on 29 January 2014. Bookmark and Share. Security researchers at Ben Gurion University in Israel are on a roll when it comes to discovering Android security flaws, and they revealed the existence of a critical flaw in the latest mobile OS version.
Android security hole could enable attackers to bypass VPNFierceMobileIT

all 3 news articles »

“android security” – read more